Cinely

AI Dungeon Alternatives With Images and Video

Cinely Team··14 min
A hooded adventurer holding a lantern at the entrance of a dark dungeon

Your ranger forgot her own name again, the story card you wrote an hour ago is being ignored, and the AI just wrote three lines of dialogue for your character. If that's why you're looking for an AI Dungeon alternative, you're in good company. Forgetting is the most common complaint in its recent low-star reviews, and the AI taking over your character is a growing one.

The honest answer is that no app fixes everything. Open text games give you the most freedom and the most forgetting. Character-chat apps add personalities, plus heavy ads and limits. Curated worlds hold together but give you less say. Images or video give you something to watch, at a price per scene. New to the genre? Start with what an AI RPG actually is.

Why are players looking for an AI Dungeon alternative?

AI Dungeon's pitch is simple: type any action, and the AI narrates what happens. Its most-liked low-star reviews on Google Play still date from 2020 to 2022, when players fought a new content filter, staff review of private stories, an energy bar and ads every 10 actions. Those complaints have nearly disappeared from recent reviews.

Today's reasons are about the story engine. In AI Dungeon's low-star reviews from the past year, about a quarter mention the AI forgetting names, race, gender, levels, inventory or side characters. One App Store reviewer said you need a notebook because "the AI will forget your character's name, race, sex and class." Another quarter describe a mobile app that broke after updates, and a smaller, growing group says the AI now writes their character's actions and dialogue.

Paying doesn't make it go away. Reviewers on paid tiers, which they put at about $30 a month, report the same forgetting, and one says larger stories hit the 8k context limit easily. As another App Store reviewer put it: "I should not have to pay for something the AI should already have by default." The mechanics are the same in every app, so read our guide to why AI forgets your story and how to fix it before you move anywhere.

What do players complain about in AI RPG apps?

Switching apps mostly trades one set of problems for another. In September 2026 we read more than 1,100 one- and two-star reviews of AI Dungeon, Character.AI, Chai and Talkie on the App Store, Google Play and Trustpilot. Five complaints kept coming back.

Forgetting. Every app drew it: about one in seven of Chai's low-star reviews and one in ten of Talkie's. Talkie's most-liked one on Google Play came from a player who bought Talkie+ for its memory upgrade and says nothing changed. On Character.AI, a review with more than 5,000 thumbs-up describes reminding characters of the same things five minutes into a chat.

Filters that block ordinary scenes. From late August 2026, Talkie reviewers describe a "please change your topic" message blocking plain story actions, like opening a door or a character's panic attack, even on adult accounts. It shows up in about 40% of Talkie's recent low-star reviews. Chai players say a 2026 filter misreads ordinary numbers, and Character.AI players report harmless, friendly gestures being filtered. We explain why, and how to rewrite a blocked scene, in content violations that seem to come from nowhere.

Limits and cooldowns. Nearly half of Chai's low-star reviews mention message limits, and in September 2026 it added "pieces", which one reviewer says are spent on every chat and even on a refresh. Character.AI reviewers describe caps on go-ons and swipes, then cooldowns they put at 7 to 24 hours. Talkie players describe waiting 30 minutes, paying or watching an ad every few messages.

Ads. For Character.AI and Chai, ads come up in more than four in ten low-star reviews, and in over a third of Talkie's. "Ads constantly interrupt characters and chats," one App Store reviewer of Character.AI wrote. Others describe an ad that restarts the app and wipes the message they were typing.

Price and lost stories. Money comes up in about half of the low-star reviews we read for these apps, and the anger peaks when a paid tier doesn't fix memory. Chai reviewers say monthly plans became weekly ones at much higher prices. Chai's most-liked low-star review on Google Play, with nearly 4,500 thumbs-up, came from a player who found almost all their chats deleted, and Talkie reviewers say web sync only covers the last 60 days.

These are unhappy players by definition, and apps change quickly. Still, on Google Play, low-star reviews made up about three quarters of those we sampled for Character.AI and Chai, against under a third for AI Dungeon and Talkie.

Why do these problems keep happening?

Memory is a budget. The model doesn't remember your adventure. Each time you act, the app sends it a slice of text: instructions, your cards, perhaps a summary, and as many recent turns as fit in its context window. Anything that doesn't fit is invisible for that turn. A bigger window costs more to run, which is why better memory is sold as an upgrade, and even a big window fills up in a long campaign.

Filters are automatic and cautious. Classifiers scan your text, and often the reply, for risky patterns. They match words and situations, not intent, so a panic attack or a number can look like something else. After a policy change, false positives tend to spike until the filter is tuned.

Free play has to be paid for somehow. Every reply runs on expensive hardware. Free apps recover the cost with ads, caps, cooldowns or tokens, and tighten those levers when costs rise.

Pictures and video cost far more than text. An image or video clip takes much more computing than a paragraph, so apps limit visuals, charge for them, or both. Players notice when a picture fails: Character.AI reviewers describe image generation failing again and again.

What should a good AI Dungeon alternative have?

Before you pay for anything, spend one free session testing these. They match the problems players report most.

  1. Memory you can see and edit. Look for story cards, a memory field or a summary you can correct. Play 20 turns, then ask the narrator about something from the first scene.
  2. Control of your own character. Watch whether the AI writes your lines, and how quickly you can delete them if it does.
  3. A filter you can live with. Try an ordinary scene from your genre, like a sword fight. Note whether the app says why something was blocked, and whether a blocked or failed turn still costs you.
  4. Limits stated up front. Find the message cap, cooldown or energy rule, and check whether rerolls count against it.
  5. Ads that stay out of the scene. Play ten minutes on the free tier and count the interruptions.
  6. A paid tier that fixes what you care about. If the upgrade only removes ads or timers, the forgetting stays. Watch for weekly billing.
  7. Stories that last. Check for auto-deletion, sync limits between phone and web, and a way to copy out your notes.
  8. The real app. Check the developer's name. When we looked for NovelAI in the app stores, the apps using its name were third-party clones.

Which AI RPGs show images or video instead of only text?

Several do, with mixed results, and not every player wants it. Under one in ten of the low-star reviews we read mention images at all, and most of those are about image features breaking. Here is what reviewers and critics describe:

  • AI Dungeon has offered image generation; a 2023 Google Play review calls the images low quality whatever style you pick.
  • Character.AI has image generation, but reviewers report frequent failures, and a review with nearly 500 thumbs-up complains you can no longer upload pictures during a chat for roleplay visuals.
  • Chai offers photo generation, and some players wish it didn't. A Google Play review with more than 2,700 thumbs-up says: "I don't want the voice and images and video."
  • Talkie has one reviewer asking for video to be added, and another noting that a custom voice clone feature was removed.
  • NovelAI is text-first, with an image generator focused on anime-style art.
  • Hidden Door uses hand-drawn card art rather than generated scenes, according to its FAQ.
  • Cinely renders each step of an interactive story as video scenes. If you want AI roleplay with video rather than still pictures, this is that format.

So an AI RPG with images is only an upgrade if the visuals are reliable, fairly priced and don't eat your balance when they fail. If you're weighing an AI Dungeon alternative with images against a video one, our comparison of text RPGs and AI video RPGs covers the trade-offs, and how AI video handles voices, sound and subtitles covers the audio side.

Which alternative fits the way you play?

Pros and cons below come from reviewers and critics. Apps change often, so read recent reviews before you pay.

Deep text and total freedom

AI Dungeon is the open sandbox: you can type any action. The catch is the story engine, with recent reviewers reporting forgetting, repetitive replies, the AI taking over their character and a buggy mobile app.

NovelAI is a text-first web app from Anlatan. Hacker News threads from 2022 present it as the escape route for AI Dungeon fans unhappy with the filter. We couldn't reach enough user reviews to judge it: there's no official mobile app, and its main complaint venues, Reddit and Discord, were out of our reach. The one critical note we found says you have to prompt it along to get the words you need.

Characters to talk to

Character.AI, Chai and Talkie are built around chatting with characters rather than narrating an adventure. If you want a Character AI alternative for roleplay, Chai and Talkie are the closest in format, and in 2026 all three draw the same heavy complaints: ads, message caps and misfiring filters. Character.AI reviewers add account checks that lock out adult users, Chai reviewers add weekly pricing and deleted chats, and one Talkie reviewer estimates its memory at about 20 lines.

A world that holds together

Hidden Door runs the other way from a sandbox. You play inside prepared worlds illustrated with hand-drawn cards. We found no user reviews, only two critics, and both describe a story that holds together but leaves little room to invent. One wrote that you can steer and remix but not conjure; the other found a choice had no meaningful effect on the story.

Choice-based story games such as Episode, Chapters and Choices go further. The story is written in advance, so nothing gets forgotten, but you pick from menus, and reviewers' top complaint is paying gems for the good options. Our guide to story games like Episode without gems covers that side of the genre.

Your story on screen

Interactive AI video stories turn each step into short video scenes. Cinely works this way, as a choose your own adventure AI app on the web, iOS and Android: you pick or type an action, and the next scenes are rendered from it. The catches are a price per scene, a strict filter and the fact that it's AI-generated video, which some players simply don't want.

TypeExamplesWhat it does wellMain catch reported
Open text sandboxAI DungeonType any actionForgetting, AI writing your character, mobile bugs
Text-first web appNovelAIText first, anime-style image toolToo few reachable reviews to judge
Character chatCharacter.AI, Chai, TalkieOngoing chats with charactersAds, message limits, filter false positives
Curated worldsHidden DoorA story that holds together; free tierCritics say little player agency
Written choice gamesEpisode, Chapters, ChoicesNothing forgotten; written branchesPaid choices, wait timers
Interactive AI videoCinelyYour action becomes video scenes; your photo as referenceCredits per scene, strict filter, AI video

Is there an AI RPG without message limits or ads?

Not a free one, in our research. Every free option comes with a trade: ads, caps, cooldowns, tokens, a weaker free model or a daily allowance. What you can find is a trade that's clear up front.

AI Dungeon's energy and ad complaints now barely appear, though one recent reviewer says its free models can no longer tell stories. Hidden Door's free tier gives unlimited stories in up to five worlds but one character conversation a day. The chat-first apps lean hardest on ads and limits. For more options that run without an install, see our roundup of AI RPG games you can play in your browser.

The other model is paying per use: you pay for what you generate, and you can see the price of a turn before you take it. That's how Cinely prices interactive stories, with no passes, energy or wait timers, just credits for each scene. The Cinely website shows no ads. The free mobile app does, and Premium turns them off.

How does Cinely's interactive AI story mode compare?

Cinely is an AI movie maker, and its interactive stories are its AI RPG mode. Here's how it measures up, including where it falls short. For a walkthrough, see how Cinely's interactive stories work.

Starting a story. You pick a template, then set your character's name, gender and photo, plus the visual style, aspect ratio and language. Cinely can generate stories in 17 languages. The opening is two video scenes for 60 credits.

Control. At every step you pick a suggested choice, type your own action of up to 500 characters, or leave the box empty and let the AI continue. Each step renders 2, 4, 6 or 8 video scenes at 30 credits a scene, so a default two-scene step costs 60.

Your character's look. Your photo is turned into a styled, full-body reference image that scenes are generated from, so your lead is anchored to a picture rather than a line of text. The video provider's automatic check declines many photos of real people, often including your own, so you may need another photo or an illustrated portrait.

Memory. Cinely doesn't promise to remember every detail of a long adventure. Plot details and other characters can still drift, which is why short steps and restating names in your typed action help.

Limits and failures. There are no passes, energy bars or wait timers, so you can play as long as your credits last. If an opening or a step fails to render, its credits come back automatically, and a partial failure is refunded for the lost scenes. A step that rendered but that you dislike isn't refunded.

The filter. A third-party safety filter can block a scene for violence, sexual content, real or famous people, hateful language about a group, self-harm or copyrighted material, and spoken dialogue can be blocked on its own. Graphic combat and mature scenes are likely to be stopped.

Price. It isn't free. An interactive story charges only for the scenes it renders, but they add up: an opening plus nine default steps is 600 credits. New accounts get a one-time welcome gift, 180 credits by default, though the amount can vary. Credit prices depend on your store and region, and some templates need Cinely Premium.

One account. Credits and Premium belong to your account on the web, iOS and Android. If you start the app as a guest, link Google or Apple to keep your coins and progress.

Which alternative should you pick?

Pick by the problem that made you leave.

  • To write long prose and control every word, stay with text, and test the memory tools first.
  • For a character to talk to, play a chat app's free tier for a week before paying, and count the ads and limits.
  • For a story that holds together, try curated worlds or a written choice game, and accept less freedom.
  • To see your character act out your choices, try interactive video, and budget for credits per scene.

For that last route, browse fantasy stories on Cinely for a setting you like, then start your own interactive story with one clear character in mind.

Is there an official NovelAI app on the App Store or Google Play?
Not when we checked in September 2026. NovelAI, made by Anlatan, runs as a web app. Searching both stores turned up third-party apps that borrow the name, such as "Novel AI - AI Story Generator", and none of them come from Anlatan. If you want NovelAI itself, use it in your browser, and read the developer name carefully before you subscribe to anything that looks like it.
Is Hidden Door free to play?
Partly. According to its pricing page, the free tier gives you unlimited stories in up to five worlds and one character conversation a day, and there is a paid tier called Atlas, priced in the app. Its art is hand-drawn cards rather than generated scenes. We found no user reviews to judge it by, only two critics, who describe a story that holds together but leaves the player little room to invent.
Do rerolls and refreshes count against limits in AI chat apps?
Often, yes. Chai reviewers say its new pieces are spent on every chat and even on a refresh, and Character.AI's free limits cover swipes as well as go-ons. Check this before you count on rerolls to fix bad replies. In Cinely's interactive stories every step is paid in credits, a failed opening or step is refunded automatically, and a step that rendered but that you dislike is not refunded.
Will I lose my AI RPG stories if I stop playing for a while?
It depends on the app, so check before you invest weeks in a campaign. Chai reviewers report chats deleted after days of inactivity or when open chats hit a cap, and Talkie reviewers say web sync only covers chats from the last 60 days. AI Dungeon reviewers describe long world-building sessions lost after crashes. Keep copies of your character cards, notes and recaps outside the app so you can rebuild a story anywhere.
Can I play an AI RPG in a language other than English?
Some apps handle it better than others. Talkie reviewers report replies that suddenly switch to Chinese characters mid-message. When you start a Cinely interactive story you choose its language, and Cinely can generate stories in 17 languages or detect the language automatically. Whatever app you use, play a few turns in your language before paying, because quality can differ from English.

Written with AI assistance and edited by the Cinely Team.